The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 review: invest, spend, repeat

Sometimes, however, a recipe that sounded delicious, made by a beloved chef, doesn’t quite dazzle the judges as we’d hoped. 

That’s what I think happened here with The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1. It should have been a sensational hit: 

• The chef, M1 Finance, was a crowd favorite with rave reviews on the App Store and Play Store. 
• The recipe sounded amazing: a rewards card that generates up to 10% cash back 

It was all set up to win, but I think M1 Finance just pulled it out of the oven too quickly. Not only are there a few ingredients missing – but the base of the card leaves a bitter aftertaste. 

That being said, I do think there’s a certain type of investor that will still find The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 “delicious.” 

• Best for – M1 users who invest in individual assets.
• Intro offer/sign-up bonus – None.
• Cash back – Everyone can earn 1.5% on all purchases, and M1 Plus members can earn 2.5%, 5%, or 10% on 75 various large retailers, airlines, and other name brands.
• Intro APR – None.
• Regular APR –  Variable.
• Other notable features – Visa Signature® benefits including hotel discounts and ID theft protection.

Let’s break down the individual pieces of The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1, starting with its incredibly unique rewards structure. 

Rewards

I’ve been reviewing credit cards for years, and I can say with absolute confidence that The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 has the most unique and complex rewards structure I’ve seen. 

Buckle up. 

Ok, so to even begin unpacking this card’s reward system, I have to explain how M1 Finance works. 

M1 Finance is built for passive, long-term investing. The whole purpose of the app is to build “lazy portfolios” that you design once, fund, and otherwise let sit so they can mature and grow your money without intervention. 

M1 Finance helps you build “Pies,” which are like lazy portfolios made up of individual assets, ETFs, and even other Pies. M1 Finance themselves curates over 80 Pies with various themes like the 60/40 Pie (60% stocks and 40% bonds) and the Moderately Aggressive Pie. 

There’s also a social, dare I say, collaborative element to M1 Finance since you can chat Pies on the M1 Finance subreddit. If you like another user’s Pies, you can search for it, add it to your Pie, and share in the spoils. 

The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 is M1 Finance’s first credit card. It’s a premium rewards card clearly trying to peel M1 users away from their big bank cards. 

So how does it all work, and how can you score some 10% cash back rewards? 

The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 offers four tiers of rewards for M1 Plus members: 

1. 10% cash back on purchases from 14 major companies including Chewy, Tesla, and Netflix.
2. 5% cash back on 20 more companies including Starbucks, Southwest, and UPS.
3. 2.5% cash back on 39 more companies including Apple, Amazon, and AT&T.
4. 1.5% cash back on all other purchases.

You can see the complete list of companies and rewards tiers here. In total, you’ll get 2.5% cash back or higher on purchases from 75 very big, very recognizable companies. 

Is there a catch? Of course. Two of them, in fact. 

• Maximum $200 per month earn rate. Sadly, no, you can’t save 10% or $4,000 on a new Tesla Model 3. It’s also a bummer that the 1.5% cash back category isn’t unlimited like it is with most rewards cards – even those with no annual fee. 
• You have to be an M1 Plus member to receive tiered cash back. 

APR

The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 charges variable APR based on the prime rate. 

That’s honestly lower than I thought it would be – premium rewards cards, especially those with high qualification requirements, tend to charge the maximum possible interest rates (because why not?). 

Even still, you want to avoid missing a payment with this card at all costs since there’s no late payment forgiveness – your missed payment will start accruing interest (and be reported to Experian to lower your credit score) right away.

Other fees

Start combing through The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1’s terms & conditions, and you’ll soon run into the card’s other fees. 

First thing’s first, The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 charges no foreign transaction fees. It also charges zero balance transfer or cash advance fees because – get this – it doesn’t allow balance transfers or cash advances. 

The last of The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1’s fees worth mentioning are the penalty fees: 

• Late Payment – $25.
• Over-the-Credit Limit – None.
• Returned Payment – Up to $37.

Not much to unpack here, aside from the fact that these fees are surprisingly low for a premium, paid rewards card. Late payment fees are typically $40 at least. 

Perks and benefits

The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 is a Visa Signature® card, meaning it includes a nice assortment of money-saving, stress-reducing, and downright bougie perks. 

Not all Visa Signature® cards are exactly the same, but The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 includes these perks and more: 

• ID Navigator powered by NortonLifeLife – High-caliber ID theft protection.
• Roadside Dispatch – Pay-per-use roadside assistance.
• Travel & emergency assistance services – 24/7, multilingual reps you can call for help rebooking travel, seeking medical care overseas, etc.
• Visa’s Zero Liability Policy – Basically super-duper fraud protection.
• Emergency Card Replacement – They’ll ship you another card within 24 to 72 hours globally.
• Cardholder inquiry service – “Personalized support” from Visa Signature® card experts.

I mentioned that some of the Visa Signature® perks are downright bougie, and here are the prime examples:

• Visa Signature Luxury Hotel Collection – Didn’t I promise bougie? With The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 you’ll get instant higher status at over 900 Visa Signature Luxury Hotel partners.
• Silvercar by Audi – Get a discount on Audi rentals from this unique service.
• Sonoma Wine Country – The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 grants you unique perks and discounts at various participating Sonoma-area wineries. 
• Troon Rewards – Grab your clubs, since The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 will help you save at over 95 golf courses worldwide. 

Fidelity® Rewards Visa Signature® Card

The Fidelity® Rewards Visa Signature® Card certainly takes the cake as the simplest investor rewards card. You’ll get an unlimited 2% back on all purchases, which you can either redeem as cash back or invest it into your Fidelity investment account. 

Naturally, the Fidelity® Rewards Visa Signature® Card is exclusive to Fidelity customers – but if that’s you, and you’d like a card that automatically invests for you, it’s a strong choice. 

Chase Freedom Unlimited®

The Chase Freedom Unlimited® is not an investing credit card, but it is one of the best overall rewards cards on the market. 

To start, you’ll get a sign up bonus of unlimited Matched Cash Back when you use your card for all purchases. At the end of your first year, Chase will automatically match all cash back earned with no limits or rewards caps.. Earn 5% cash back on travel booked through Chase Ultimate Rewards®; 3% on dining and drugstore purchases; and an unlimited 1.5% cash back on all other purchases. Bonus rewards are valid in the first year or after $20,000 in purchases.

Will it automatically invest your cash back? No, but you can always cash it out and invest it manually.

In its current state, The Owner’s Rewards Card by M1 is really only a fit for those who can benefit by shopping at the companies in the 5% and 10% categories.

I’ll admit, that’s a narrow group of folks.